Hahaha…reminiscing to back when the www was new…

and an old friend crossed my mind: The Mid-Majority

Funny isn’t it…The more things change, the more theY remain the same.

The Mid-Majority was many things to basketball purists. It was a calendar tracking Kyle Whellinston’s annual sojourne across the nation – visiting college campuses and taking in games (80 or more) annually. Games predominantly of smaller schools and of campuses off the beaten track. It was a rant page, if you will, where fans of the non-major schools could sound off. It was an information source, as Whelliston was a professional journalist/writer.

The Redline:

Possibly, the site’s greatest gift was Kyle’s “The Red Line” article. In it he cited a calculated $20 Million (USD) line of demarcation. The conferences of the ‘haves – Majors’ spent an average of $20 million or more annually on athletics. The ‘havenots – Mid-Majors’ less than $20 Million annual athletics budgets. There had previously been no form of demarcation and a myriad of terms were bantied about to describe the very real ‘divide’ between the haves and have-nots. Purportedly, Coach Jack Kvancz came up with the term, during his tenure at Catholic University (of America), in D.C..

The term mid-major traces back to 1977 when Catholic University coach Jack Kvancz described his team’s game against Howard as “two mid-majors, or whatever you’d call us.”

Mid-Major Rehash:

In a 2019 an Oct. 23rd NYT article (see below) writer Brian Bennett re-examined the phenomenon. He argued that perhaps a new measure was in order. He suggested shifting the onus away from conferences to individual schools. A new demarcation line of $6 Million annual expenditure per school (in Basketball). He spelled it out nicesly too, complete with spreadsheet. LOL.

Some things don’t change…Them that got – Spend! The same Louisville’s, UK’s, Duke’s, etc , have continued the budgetary arms race Add in ‘legal’ fan combines, NIL, University profit-sharing, and the spending is out of control. However, such a shift in focus towards runaway spending, neglects the other underlying premise of the original ‘Red Line’!

Shifting the focus away from conferences clouds the issue of the Majors/P4/P5 stranglehold on post-season tournament bids, especially NCAA Tournament bids. This is highly significant with the erosion of the other postseason tourneys (CBI, CIT, the Crown) and the cessation of the NIT as a post-season destination for non-NCAA qualifiers.

2027 NCAA Tourney Expansion:

With the advent of a 76-team NCAA field, the Majors and the vast majority of media talking heads envision the P5 elites taking the majority of the extended field. Whereas the Majors previously garnered 5 Autobids, they gobbled up 31 to 33 (36-38 bids annually) of the Selection Sunday bids as well – leaving non-majors a max of 5 Selection Sunday bids (and 26 conf autobids). Now with 45 bids up for grabs in the new expanded format, they are eyeing more — possibly all 45!

An ecquitable solution is for the NCAA to cap conference bids at 8 teams/year. The ‘middlin majors’ of the P5 conferences would have to compete within their conferences to gain one of the capped bids, No more .500 teams getting into the NCAA Tourney. If a conference has less than 8 teams over .500, those forfeited bids go to other deserving non-major teams. ExP.: Big-10 and SEC only have 6 .500+ teams. The other 2 bids allocated for them would be forfeited that season and those bids awarded to deserving non-major teams in the hunt for a NCAA berth. No more 9-11 bids for P5 ‘middlin’ majors’.

By capping the P5 conferences @ 8-teams (40 total), the NCAA assures nonmajor conferences a fair shake with a minimum of a 36-team representation (26 autobids/10 Selection Sunday bids) in each years NCAA Tournament. In years where P5 teams falter, more non–major participationn ensures the ‘Dance’ atmosphere is electric with increased Cinderella upset potentials! Good for the game. Capping the P4/5 NCAA bids may force the NCAA to reinstate the postseaason NIT for their precious .500 or worse middlin’ majors. The other postseason tourneys have all folded their tents and gone home.

PS: What a week so far, as several ranked P5 teams have bit the dust. A highly competitive non-conference slate is good for the game, Intense competitiion sorts out the overrated ‘beauty queen’ teams so favored by the media and coaches, and gives opportunities for other top 50 squads to crack the early Top 25 venues. We need every season to feature more top 25 head-to-head contests…makes for great fan interest, a more fluid and mobile top 20 to 35 fluctuation amongst top teir teams, and weeds out the beauty contest ‘pretenders’ early. Good for the game!

The More things Change…the more they remain the Same!

James Harvey, a.k.a. @gtmoblue

LINKS:

Leave a Reply